Hello dear
Welcome To Jerry & Sal’s Pizza
At Jerry & Sal’s Pizza, located in Hanover, PA, culinary passion meets community spirit. The brand, beloved by locals for years, specializes in authentic New York-style pizza and hearty subs. Their signature Parmigiana Subs, featuring tender chicken or homemade meatballs smothered in zesty marinara and melted cheese, are a must-try. Customers rave about the friendly staff and warm atmosphere, making each visit a delightful experience. Desserts, like the crispy cannoli filled with sweet ricotta, add a perfect finishing touch. Whether you’re craving a classic pizza or an indulgent cheesesteak sub, Jerry & Sal’s promises a memorable meal for every palate.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Onion Rings
Lasagna
Marinara Sauce
Cheddar Cheese
About
Jerry & Sal’s Pizza
Welcome to Jerry & Sal's Pizza, a cherished gem nestled in the heart of Hanover, Pennsylvania. This is more than just a restaurant; it’s a local institution that has been delighting visitors and residents alike since its inception. Located at 1155 Carlisle St, Jerry & Sal's Pizza stands out with its inviting atmosphere and a menu that promises an authentic taste of New York-style pizza.
As you enter, the warm, friendly ambiance immediately sets the tone for an enjoyable dining experience. The staff's welcoming demeanor enhances the atmosphere, making it a go-to spot for families and friends alike. Many loyal customers have shared their stories of making Jerry & Sal’s a part of their lives—some have been savoring the pizza for decades, recalling cherished moments within these walls.
The menu is a delightful showcase of Italian-American classics. Here are some highlights:
- Cheese Stuffed Shells: Pasta shells generously filled with ricotta and mozzarella, crowned with zesty marinara. Priced at $11.95, it’s comfort food at its finest.
- Baked Ziti: This dish features ziti pasta beautifully tossed in a marinara and ricotta blend, generously topped with melted mozzarella. A hearty option for $11.95.
- Lasagna: A layered masterpiece filled with ground beef and various cheeses, topped with more ooey-gooey mozzarella—all for $11.95. It’s the kind of meal that feels like a warm hug.
And let's not forget the sweet finish—senior to any meal is a homemade cannoli that brings smiles as wide as the plates they serve. Customers rave about their experience, often remarking on the unforgettable flavors and generous portions that define a visit to Jerry & Sal’s.
Drinks are also covered, featuring refreshing options like a 2L bottle of Diet Coke for just $3.00. For those looking for a bite alongside their favorite pizza, extras such as garlic knots and various sauces are readily available, ensuring that every meal is perfectly personalized.
The reviews speak for themselves: patrons like Cassandra Millius highlight the delightful blend of friendly service and exquisite New York oven-made pizza, while Michael Lenahan reflects on a lifetime of loyalty to the establishment despite changes around it. It's this blend of history and flavor that keeps customers coming back.
While some reviews mention variations in crust thickness and taste, what remains undisputed is the community love and the commitment of Jerry & Sal’s Pizza to provide a delightful culinary experience. From its homemade pasta dishes to its delicious, gooey pizzas, Jerry & Sal’s is a must-try for anyone who finds themselves in Hanover. If you haven’t already, make your way to this local treasure and create your own delicious memories. You won't regret it!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ It's a wonderful restaurant. Nice interior. If you are a pizza lover this is the place for you especially if you like New York oven made pizza. The staff are very friendly and welcoming they also have delicious home made cannoli s. ”
“ So I have been eating here most of my life 35 I've been eating there since I was at least 6 and at some fortunate the mall is disintegrating around it or dying I shouldn't say disintegrating but dying around it but they still have great pizza it's been a while since I've been there and going to have to remember to get it from there more often if I live closer I definitely would but your friends in New Oxford now so maybe I can swing in there and pick up a pizza and take it up in the future highly recommend the trees or pizza I had it for the first time today and oh wow that was good. ”
“ Five stars because it's just a great Hanover business. However, it's not as good as I remember. Pizza was a bit thin and greasy. It's better than some other pizza joints, though. I got a steak calzone. Although is it really a calzone if it doesn't come with ricotta cheese? It was also a bit smaller than other Strombolis I've had recently. It's still a good place ”
“ The manager and the staff are all wonderful and hard-working. As much as I enjoy their pizza, I had a cheesesteak sub there last week that was so good, I had tears in my eyes!! He even gave me a garlic knot to enjoy while I waited. ”
“ Great little local spot to get a pizza. I was hot and delicious. ”
“ Not sure about the food because all I order is pizza. They make the best New York Pizza I've had in Central PA. Highly recommend for pizza. I cannot speak for their other entrees because I've never tried them. I did get a steak sub for a friend who said it was excellent. ”
“ Our high school marching band was attending Calvacade Championships in New Oxford, PA, (2.5 hrs. from home) and needed to feed around 150 after our performance. Armando handled the job perfectly and knew what he was doing — not only did he personally deliver hot pizza for that many, but the pizza was sooooo delicious!!! I would work with him again in a heartbeat. ”
“ Best pizza, no doubt about it. I’ve been going here since I was little and the consistency of flavor, quality, and service has never failed. Shoutout for the free cheesecake! It was delicious with the cookie! ”